Warnings on ‘unsustainable’ international tuition fee hikes

[mkt]

As international student recruitment becomes more challenging, universities in the UK are increasingly turning to tuition fee hikes to boost their financial income. However, experts are warning that this approach may have long-term consequences, especially as universities try to balance declining student numbers and financial deficits.

Some institutions, like the University of York and the University of Manchester, have raised tuition fees for international students, sometimes above inflation, to compensate for lower demand. The University of York, for instance, increased its international tuition fees by 12% for the 2023-24 academic year, despite a drop in international student enrollment.

This pattern is not unique to York, as many UK universities have faced reduced deficits by increasing international student fees, even as enrollment numbers decline. The shift from a post-COVID boom to a more competitive global student market, influenced by factors like visa policies, geopolitical instability, and rising costs of studying in the UK, has created a perfect storm for these institutions.

Rising Fees May Lead to Geopolitical Risks and Market Dependency
Raising fees in response to falling demand raises significant risks. Many UK universities are heavily dependent on international students, particularly from China, and could face severe financial strain if they alienate these markets. The University of Manchester's experience highlights the issue: while international student fees increased by £54.4 million in 2023, the university remains vulnerable to fluctuations in international demand.

As universities push for higher tuition fees, experts like David Pilsbury caution that this could alienate prospective students, especially as alternative study destinations like Australia, Canada, and the United States become increasingly attractive. The risk is not just financial; it could undermine the UK's reputation as a study destination, particularly as rankings for some universities fall. For example, the University of York saw its position drop in the QS World University Ranking, which could further reduce its appeal to international students.

The Impact of Overly Optimistic Projections
Some universities and regulators have projected substantial growth in international student numbers and income, assuming that tuition fees will continue to rise. However, experts like Dr. Janet Ilieva of Education Insight warn that these projections are overly optimistic. Many international students, particularly from China, are already questioning the return on investment (ROI) of studying in the UK, given the rising costs.

Ilieva also argues that constant fee increases without a corresponding increase in value could tarnish the reputation of UK universities as "greedy" institutions. At the same time, international students have growing options for studying closer to home, such as regional programs in Asia, which may be more cost-effective than studying in the UK.

The Need for a Sustainable Approach
The higher education sector in the UK needs to rethink its strategy for international student recruitment. Instead of relying on fee hikes, universities should focus on improving operational efficiency, diversifying their student populations, and enhancing the value of the student experience. This could involve greater investment in partnerships, such as foundation years or dual-degree programs with overseas institutions, to create more affordable pathways for international students.

Ultimately, UK universities must recognize that tuition fee hikes may not be a sustainable solution. As competition for international students intensifies and costs continue to rise, they must find more balanced, long-term strategies to ensure their financial health while maintaining their global reputation and appeal.